I just got back from seeing Red Tails. I enjoyed it.
Was it corny? Of course... but no more so than some of the old classics. Find me a war movie that isn't cliche' in some way and I'll buy you a beer.
Was it overly heroic? Of course... but so are nearly all the old war movies we all saw as kids. If you honestly think this was more overly heroic than Flying Tigers, or Sands of Iwo, or pretty much any other movie John Wayne ever starred in, you need to get off your high horse. But then again, those are "classics" so maybe they are beyond reproach
Were there historical inaccuracies? Sure... but they weren't any worse than the Hellcats in Midway, or the Spitfire MK IXs in Battle of Britain.
The dialogue was a little awkward, but I have seen very few war movies where it isn't. The heroic, macho dialogue is played up in so many movies that it doesn't bother me anymore. Thankfully it wasn't as bad as Pearl Harbor in this regard.
The CGI was very good in some areas, and poor in others. In some parts, it was difficult to tell whether real aircraft were being used or not. Many of CGI scenes looked slightly like a video game or flight simulator, but at least everything was accurately shaped for the most part. There were only a couple angles and scenes that really seemed off. The on ground sets were spectacular. There were so many interesting uniforms and equipment to look at that I found myself getting distracted from the plot.
I was entertained. I don't think it's any worse than any of the classic war movies my Dad showed me when I was growing up. It was a very entertaining way to spend an afternoon, and I'll probably pick it up on DVD when it comes out. I just hope I'm not as grumpy and cynical about everything as some of you are by then
