Holedigger wrote:
I've often wondered about the legality of the Russians holding German POWs so long after the war. No trial, just holding them. That and the US turning over Luftwaffe pilots back to Russia? Combine that with the 95% mortality of the Stalingrad POWs. Geneva Convention? What is that!? The Eastern front was appallingly dirtier war on both sides.
Legality had nothing to do with it- there was no Geneva agreement between Germany and Russia...
The fact the Russians did not sign the Geneva Accords with Germany lead directly to the tragic abuse of Russian POWs in German hands during the war. Almost every US/Brit POW memoire I have read speaks of the Russians, and how glad the American and British POWs were that their countries had been signators! The Russian POWs were treated as disposable resources, often worked literally to death, and left barely fed or clothed. They were truly treated as badly as the Concentration Camp victims. One of the most interesting stories out of those camps was about one of the German guards who had an Alsatian(like a larger German Shepard) guard dog. He let it get all riled up, and laughed as he set it loose in one of the Russian barracks, delighting in the thought of the Ivans being bitten. From fierce barking, it went to yelping: Very shortly, the yelping stopped. The guard waited a few minutes, and slunk away as he realized his dog no longer existed as such...
The Japanese treated American POWs equally poorly, with the experiments in China really bringing them on par with their allies for cruelty.
Meanwhile, German, and those few Japanese POWs were treated very well here, in the US & Canada until the end of the war, with many choosing to settle here after the war!
Hans Von Luck, a Panzer Colonel, was held into the early 1950s after being captured during the fall of Berlin. After regular interrogations for several years after the war, he had enough, and yelled at his captors "I was only a German Soldier doing my duty! I know nothing of what the High Command did! I was just a field officer!" Apparently, after 5 years, and numerous attempts to get them to listen, and understand he knew nothing they did not already know, they finally believed him, and released him to West Germany. Read "Panzer Commander" by hans Von Luck, for more details.
Robbie
Robbie