This is the place where the majority of the warbird (aircraft that have survived military service) discussions will take place. Specialized forums may be added in the new future
Post a reply

Mass WWII airborne drop?

Sat Oct 13, 2007 7:25 pm

We are thinking about a mass C-47/airborne drop into our WWII battle, Would it be worth it?

Sat Oct 13, 2007 8:04 pm

I think it would be worth it if you could get at least 3 to 4 C-47/R4D aircraft flying over and dropping at least 10 +or- paratroopers from each aircraft. Much less than that would not really be even a rough approximation of a true "Mass" airdrop, and may not be worth the effort and trouble.

Just my humble opinion - I know that you and others will give us a Great show next August.

Re: Mass WWII airborne drop?

Sat Oct 13, 2007 11:47 pm

michael luther wrote:We are thinking about a mass C-47/airborne drop into our WWII battle, Would it be worth it?


If you don't find a way to make this happen, I'm locking out your domain account, cutting off your internet access, and will beat you with a very large stick every time you come near the hangar from now until Thunder.

So I guess you can count this as one vote "yes"

Seriously though, with "Band of Brothers" still being recent and popular to the masses, I think this would be a sweet inclusion. (If the insurance folks don't all have a collective heart attack.) Even if it's only three or four sticks of troops, it'd be an awesome sight.

Sun Oct 14, 2007 3:33 am

Mike,
If you get that worked out it would certainly be a different look for the show. As a backup, think of maybe a re-supply drop by some C-47's during the ground battle, of course, offsetting the line of flight for the safety of the ground troops.
Later you might get a couple of sticks from Bragg to come up and make a jump from C-130's. Finish it off with a transport "Hertiage Flight" of a C-47 and C-130. We had always wanted to do a flight with the Lodestar and a Herk.
Bob
ODS/CAF

Sun Oct 14, 2007 8:22 pm

It would be unreal to see a mass air drop. It would definitely add to an already spectacular battle. Armor, fighter support, and real paratroopers all leads me to believe that it will be the greatest battle ever!

Sun Oct 14, 2007 8:33 pm

Not to be a dilwad here but I would suggest that you review the basic stats on casualties for a drop of a given size vs. military acceptable losses.

I'm sorry, but I recall a "60 Minutes" episode where a leading Army General was interviewed regarding the number of deaths associated with a "desert storm" style practice event. The number of soldiers killed with un-opened chutes, equipment issues, etc. was unreal but well within "acceptable losses" based on the number of soldiers involved. Still a staggering number for a "practice" event.

I'd hate to see catatstrophy for the sake of a show. IMHO there should be some tremendous prep done prior to the event.

If you have the goods, great! Don't go into it un-prepared. :wink:

Sun Oct 14, 2007 8:39 pm

That would be pretty cool, but only if they dropped with the round 'chutes and not the airfoil thingys. Those would spoil the effect.

Mudge the purist :D

Tue Oct 16, 2007 6:40 pm

Sounds like a winning idea to me Mike!! :D

Tue Oct 16, 2007 7:04 pm

PLEASE... YES! :D

I was waiting for someone to have this idea! Well I'm sure other groups and people have had this idea for a show but man! This will be one of the best years yet!


For my side: I hope them Tennessee boys will get up there this year! It would be cool to try and get 5 to 6 Thunderbolts on the field! Imagine a fighter sweep at 100 to 200 ft?! One peeling off after the other! But thats probably asking too much. :cry:

Tue Oct 16, 2007 7:33 pm

sdennison wrote:Not to be a dilwad here but I would suggest that you review the basic stats on casualties for a drop of a given size vs. military acceptable losses.


I believe "standard" "acceptable losses" are about 10% for modern combat jumps - losses include any type of injury rendering the jumper "combat ineffective" & range from severe sprains to death.

Peacetime training jumps have much lower losses (normally).

Most of the drops I do are small unit drops (<20), but we occasionally will fill the back of the Herk (50+). Proper safety precautions, wind limits, reserve chutes, and higher drop altitudes (~1000-1200' vs ~800' combat) result in near zero casualties for the overwhelming majority of drops.

It is a very real concern, but is by no means a risk that cannot be mitigated.

Tue Oct 16, 2007 7:53 pm

Sounds like a great idea Mike. This would be a very impressive sight to see in conjunction with the ground battle.

Eric

Tue Oct 16, 2007 8:05 pm

T2 Ernie wrote:
sdennison wrote:Not to be a dilwad here but I would suggest that you review the basic stats on casualties for a drop of a given size vs. military acceptable losses.


I believe "standard" "acceptable losses" are about 10% for modern combat jumps - losses include any type of injury rendering the jumper "combat ineffective" & range from severe sprains to death.

Peacetime training jumps have much lower losses (normally).

Most of the drops I do are small unit drops (<20), but we occasionally will fill the back of the Herk (50+). Proper safety precautions, wind limits, reserve chutes, and higher drop altitudes (~1000-1200' vs ~800' combat) result in near zero casualties for the overwhelming majority of drops.

It is a very real concern, but is by no means a risk that cannot be mitigated.


Yah, I was thinking the same thing. They drop at 1,000 feet so everyone can see them and they get good hang time, and can all get into the LZ without pulling their shoulders out of socket trying to slip. They could jump combat, but stuff their packs with packing peanuts so they're really jumping Hollywood, and stagger up and out so the jumpers won't drop into the birds behind them. That would make it pretty dooable. Wish I hadn't got fat and old, I'd be willing to do a jump like that. Wonder how hard it would be to make a fake Waco to split open so a jeep could drive out?

Tue Oct 16, 2007 9:59 pm

Glad I am not out to lunch. You guys have more experience than I but I would hope the "show" would not over power the safety factor. :wink:

Tue Oct 16, 2007 10:47 pm

well, the most I have ever seen at a show was one stick. But honestly the issue when your doing multiple sticks is mostly making sure the DZ is big enough, and the birds are very well trained at formation, and when to hit the green light. A good example of a badly trained formation drop would be DDay :oops: When guys were mowed by props, drop in the atlantic, and miles from their DZ. Because you want them all in a tight DZ you'll have to rehearse somehow, but the Air Force does it every day, right?

Tue Oct 16, 2007 10:56 pm

I have seen something on the web about a group that does WWII drops in full era gear, might be worth the search.
Post a reply