Tiger Tim wrote:
How about the official airplane 'diving noise?' That whining crescendo noise actually comes from the flying and landing wires vibrating on a biplane at high speed but don't tell the directors who attach that noise to EVERY OTHER AIRPLANE. Really, all of them. Ever.
-Tim
That's my all-time least favorite Aviation Movie Trope. I've never heard a real airplane make a sound anything like that..even aerobatic planes in a vertical dive. I've always wondered where the trope started..I though maybe it was inspired by the dive sirens on Stukas, but the sound effect was being used in movies well before that. I'd never heard that it was from the wires before, but it certainly makes sense. Of course, that means that no cantilever wing aircraft would even be capable of making that sound. Using it for anything other than a wire-braced aircraft is about as accurate as the (intentional) prop engine sound effects used for the 707 in "Airplane!"
Ironically, one of the few movies that didn't use the cheesy whine SFX was the recent "King Kong" remake. possibly because Peter Jackson is an aircraft officianado/collector. I always like it when directors start from scratch with sound rather than using tired old ckips from a library. Jackson actually sent a crew out to record a bunch of sound from a Harvard for his movie. It bodes well for his "Dambusters" project, provided it ever gets made.
Quote:
And I don't think we've had the "all helicopters have to have the Huey (Bell system) 'whop whop whop' noise" even when the blades can't make it...
Not all of them...some movie helos sound like Bell 47s...even ones that are actually turbine-powered!
Sound is one of those things that can really make or break a movie for me. I can't count the number of times I've been wrenched out of the movie by radail-engine aircrft with inline sound effects, or vice versa. or worse turboprop SFX. I remember seeing a TV show once where there was a closeup of a C-130 engine spooling up, but the SFX was a large radial engine turning over.
Speaking of over-used sound effects, how about that same tires-touching-the-runway sound effect used in every movie ever.
SN